Skip to content
NewFamily Office Governance in Canada (2026): Four Models, Eleven Providers Compared Read →
← Back to Insights
HR Services

One Over-Broad 'Cause' Definition Still Sinks the Whole Clause: Ghazvini v. CIBC and Henshell v. BFN

November 18, 2026By 1205 Consulting7 min read

Executive summary

  • In Ghazvini v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 2026 ONCA 766, released October 29, 2026, the Court of Appeal held that the Waksdale rule applies to contracts governed by the Canada Labour Code and that CIBC's broad for-cause definition voided its termination provisions.
  • In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, the Superior Court applied the Baker framework and upheld a termination clause that paid all statutory entitlements on termination for any lawful reason, despite for-cause wording elsewhere in the agreement.
  • Remove laundry lists of cause from templates, make sure every for-cause clause preserves statutory minimums, do not rely on a general compliance clause, check confidentiality and policy sections for termination language, and have counsel review the result.

Two Ontario decisions released weeks apart show both sides of termination clause drafting after Baker. In Ghazvini v. CIBC, 2026 ONCA 766, a laundry-list definition of cause voided the bank's termination provisions. In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, careful wording saved a clause. The difference was the language.

After the Court of Appeal's August decision in Baker v. Van Dolder's Home Team Inc., many employers hoped the era of termination clauses failing on a technicality was over. Two decisions released this fall show the more accurate picture. Courts will now read contracts as a whole and look for what the parties objectively intended. But a for-cause clause that strips statutory entitlements for conduct short of the legal standard will still take the whole termination provision down with it.

In Ghazvini v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 2026 ONCA 766, that is what happened to CIBC. In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, a more carefully worded agreement survived. Both cases involved federally regulated employers, but the drafting lessons apply to every Ontario employment agreement.

Ghazvini: a laundry list of cause voids the clause

CIBC terminated two employees without cause in 2022 and paid them only their minimum entitlements under the Canada Labour Code. It relied on the termination provisions in their employment agreements. The employees challenged those provisions, and the trial judge found them unenforceable in 2025.

The problem was the for-cause provision. As quoted in Cassels' analysis, it allowed CIBC to terminate "at any time without advance notice, or pay in lieu of notice, for Cause," and defined Cause to include, but not be limited to, "dishonesty, fraud, breach of trust, failure to perform your duties in a satisfactory manner," a breach of "the Code", and "a breach of any other term or condition of your employment." An employee terminated for Cause would have "no entitlement to any notice of termination, payment in lieu of notice of termination, severance or any other damages whatsoever."

On October 29, 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed CIBC's appeal. According to Fasken's summary and Law Times' report, the Court held:

  • The Waksdale rule applies to federally regulated contracts. Under Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, termination provisions are unenforceable if they fail, in whole or in part, to meet minimum employment standards. The Court found "no principled reason why the same analytic approach should not apply to employment agreements governed by the CLC," as Turnpenney Milne reports.
  • The cause definition was too broad. The listed conduct might, but would not necessarily, amount to just cause under the Code. Dishonesty, for example, can include minor conduct that would not justify dismissal without notice.
  • The general compliance clause did not save it. A general "Compliance with Legislation" provision promising to meet statutory requirements did not cure the defect.
  • Baker was distinguished, not rejected. In Baker, the for-cause language preserved minimum statutory entitlements. CIBC's provision contained no comparable language.

Because the termination provisions were void, the employees were entitled to common law reasonable notice. The Court also upheld the inclusion of variable incentive pay and annual bonus in the damages, finding CIBC had not clearly and unambiguously excluded them.

Henshell: the Baker framework saves a clause

Henshell was decided before the Court of Appeal's ruling in Ghazvini. A lawyer with 20 years of experience left her practice to become CEO of Batchewana First Nation of Ojibways (BFN), a federally regulated employer, and was terminated without cause about two and a half months later. She claimed 24 months' pay in lieu of notice and $500,000 in moral and punitive damages.

Her termination clause allowed BFN to terminate "for any lawful reason" on providing all notice, severance and other entitlements required by the Code, with no further common law notice. She did not attack that clause directly. Instead, she relied on a confidentiality provision stating that a breach of confidentiality policies "will be cause for severe discipline and/or termination of employment for cause."

As Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti and Hicks Morley explain, the Court accepted that her reading might be plausible if the words were read literally and in isolation, but held that Baker requires the agreement to be read as a whole. Read together with a termination clause that promised every statutory entitlement on termination for any lawful reason, the confidentiality language did not show an intention to contract out of the Code. The word "or" also meant not every breach would lead to termination for cause. The clause was enforceable.

The Court also struck the claims for moral and punitive damages. Her allegations concerned the reason for the dismissal, not the manner of it, and no independent actionable wrong was pleaded. Hicks Morley notes the Court confirmed that moral damages for the manner of dismissal remain available even when a termination clause is enforceable.

What it means for Ontario employers

The language still decides the case. Baker gave courts a more practical way to read contracts. It did not rescue clauses that, on their plain terms, deny statutory entitlements for conduct that falls short of the statutory standard. In Ontario, that standard for losing ESA termination and severance pay is wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty that is not trivial and has not been condoned, which is narrower than common law just cause.

Language outside the termination clause counts. In both cases, the dispute was about for-cause wording, and in Henshell it sat in a confidentiality section. Policies, codes of conduct and confidentiality clauses incorporated into an agreement can all be read against the termination provision. Fasken's authors note that language outside the principal termination clause can affect enforceability even where the employee is terminated without cause.

General saving clauses are not a safety net. A catch-all promise to comply with legislation, even one placed in the termination section, did not help CIBC. What helped in Baker and Henshell was wording tied to the for-cause or termination language itself that expressly preserved statutory entitlements.

Getting it wrong is expensive. When the termination provision falls, the employee is owed common law reasonable notice, and in Ghazvini that included incentive pay and bonus the employer had not clearly excluded.

What to do now

  1. Search your templates for laundry lists of cause. Flag any clause that treats poor performance, dishonesty, breach of any policy or breach of any term as grounds for termination without notice or pay. That is the kind of list that failed in Ghazvini.

  2. Make every for-cause clause preserve statutory minimums. Have employment counsel tie the without-notice language to the applicable statutory standard, or expressly preserve ESA or Code entitlements where that standard is not met.

  3. Do not rely on a general compliance clause. If the only protection is a separate promise to follow the law, treat the agreement as at risk.

  4. Read the whole agreement, not only the termination section. Check confidentiality, conflict of interest and policy-incorporation clauses for termination wording. Our HR services work includes template audits that map every provision that touches termination.

  5. Separate the termination decision from the manner of dismissal. An enforceable clause limits notice, but it does not protect against moral damages for a dismissal handled in a misleading or unduly insensitive way. Plan the termination meeting and the communications with the same care as the contract.

Federally regulated employers with Ontario employees, in banking, telecommunications, transportation and other sectors covered by the Code, should treat Ghazvini as a clear signal to review their agreements. Provincially regulated employers should read it as a reminder that one of the most frequent reasons Ontario termination clauses fail has not changed.

Reviewing your employment agreements after Baker and Ghazvini? 1205 Consulting helps HR teams audit templates, plan the move of existing employees onto updated agreements, and coordinate with employment counsel on the final language. Book a 30-minute consultation or contact us.

This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Ontario Court of Appeal decide in Ghazvini v. CIBC?

In Ghazvini v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 2026 ONCA 766, released October 29, 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed CIBC's appeal and upheld a Superior Court ruling that the bank's termination provisions were unenforceable. The for-cause provision allowed termination without notice or pay for a non-exhaustive list of conduct, including dishonesty and unsatisfactory performance, that might not amount to just cause under the Canada Labour Code. The Court confirmed that the Waksdale approach applies to federally regulated employment agreements, so the defective for-cause provision voided the termination provisions as a whole and the employees were entitled to common law reasonable notice.

Can a saving clause or "compliance with legislation" clause fix a defective termination provision?

A general one cannot. In Ghazvini, CIBC's termination section ended with a "Compliance with Legislation" clause promising to comply with employment standards legislation and to pay statutory minimums if any provision fell short, and both the trial court and the Court of Appeal held that it did not cure the defective for-cause provision. Commentators note that language in the for-cause provision itself that clearly preserves minimum statutory entitlements can be effective, as in Baker v. Van Dolder's Home Team Inc. The wording matters and should be reviewed by employment counsel.

Why did the termination clause survive in Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways?

In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, the termination clause allowed the employer to terminate for any lawful reason on providing all notice, severance and other entitlements required by the Canada Labour Code. The employee relied on a separate confidentiality clause stating that a breach would be cause for "severe discipline and/or termination of employment for cause." Applying the Baker framework, the Court read the agreement as a whole, found the parties objectively intended to comply with the Code, and noted that the word "or" meant not every breach would lead to termination for cause. The clause was enforceable.

Does Ghazvini matter for provincially regulated Ontario employers?

Yes, indirectly. Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc. already applies to agreements governed by the Employment Standards Act, 2000. Ghazvini is a fresh appellate example of a common way termination provisions fail, a definition of cause that is broader than the statutory standard and removes all entitlements. Ontario employers whose templates list conduct such as poor performance, dishonesty or breach of any policy as cause for termination without notice should have those clauses reviewed.

#termination-clauses#employment-contracts#just-cause#employment-standards-act#ontario-employment-law#hr-compliance#outsourced-hr-services

Get insights delivered

Practical perspectives on fractional leadership, workplace investigations, and Canadian market entry. Delivered monthly.

Ready to move?

Talk to an operator who’s done this before.