Most HR leaders have heard the warning: if you know about serious misconduct and do nothing, you may lose the right to rely on it later. The legal term is condonation, and it is the reason many employers feel pressure to terminate fast, sometimes before the facts are fully gathered.
The Ontario Court of Appeal has now shown where the line sits on one set of facts. In 2551965 Ontario Ltd. v. Warkentin, 2026 ONCA 763, the Court upheld a just cause dismissal even though the employer waited about six months after an employee threatened to hit the brokerage's new broker of record. The delay did not cost the employer its case, because the reasons for it were clear and the relationship kept deteriorating.
For Ontario employers, the decision is less a licence to wait and more a lesson in what a defensible record looks like when a decision takes time.
What happened
The employee founded a real estate brokerage in Kenora around 1990 and agreed in December 2016 to sell it to a company owned by two long-time employees. Under the share purchase agreement, he stayed on as a commissioned agent from January 1, 2017. There was no separate written employment agreement.
According to Hicks Morley's summary of the decision, the relationship broke down within months. In April 2017 the employee swore at the new broker of record and threatened to hit him. He then posted insulting notes, some about the broker, in a database staff could access. Later, he steered a client to a competing brokerage, which collected the commission.
The brokerage kept him on through its busy season and dismissed him for cause in October 2017. It sued him for breach of restrictive covenants, and he counterclaimed for wrongful dismissal.
What the courts decided
The trial judge applied the contextual just cause analysis from Hucsko v. A.O. Smith Enterprises Ltd., 2021 ONCA 728, and found that the threat of violence, the insulting communications and the conflict of interest were serious misconduct that could not be reconciled with continued employment. The judge stated there should be "zero tolerance for abusive language or threats of violence directed at anyone in the workplace." The employee's history as the founder and the new owners' former mentor did not lower that standard.
On the six-month delay, the trial judge found no condonation. As Littler's summary (written by the employer's counsel on appeal) explains, the judge accepted that the delay was not unreasonable given the unusual relationship, the employer's reliance on the employee during the busy season, and evidence that the relationship was continuing to deteriorate.
The trial judge also found that the conduct met the higher wilful misconduct standard under the Employment Standards Act, 2000, so no statutory termination pay was owed.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the employee's appeal. It found the trial judge properly applied Hucsko. The employee argued that a separate "culminating incident" was needed; the Court described that argument as "a repackaging" of the condonation argument. Even if a culminating incident were required, the Court found there was one: at the October 2017 meeting, before he was told he was terminated, the employee acknowledged that the parties no longer trusted one another.
What it means for Ontario employers
Delay is not fatal, but it has to be explained. Condonation is a question of fact. Warkentin turned on a combination of factors that will not be present in most workplaces: a former owner, a business that depended on him for one season, and fresh misconduct during the delay. JSR Legals' review of the case puts it plainly: a delay can be explained but rarely forgotten. An employer that sits on serious misconduct with no documented reason, and treats the employee as if nothing happened, is in a much weaker position.
The ESA test builds condonation in. Ontario's O. Reg. 288/01 removes the right to statutory notice and termination pay for misconduct only where the employee is guilty of "wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty that is not trivial and has not been condoned by the employer." That means delay and mixed signals can affect two separate questions: common law cause and the statutory minimums. Employers should assess them separately. Meeting the common law test does not guarantee the ESA test is met.
A threat is also a safety issue. The Occupational Health and Safety Act defines workplace violence to include "a statement or behaviour that it is reasonable for a worker to interpret as a threat to exercise physical force against the worker, in a workplace, that could cause physical injury to the worker." Under section 32.0.2 of OHSA, every employer's workplace violence program must set out how the employer will investigate and deal with incidents or complaints of workplace violence. An employer that waits months to decide on discipline after a threat still has to deal with the incident under its program in the meantime.
Seniority and history do not change the standard. The courts did not give the employee extra latitude because he had founded the business. Long service, a senior title or a close personal history with leadership will not, on their own, excuse threats or abusive conduct.
What to do now
-
Start the fact-finding right away, even if the decision will take longer. What helped this employer was credible evidence of what happened and when: witnesses to the threat, the database notes and the client's emails. Gather statements, preserve messages and database entries, and record the dates while memories are fresh. If the matter is serious or involves a senior person, consider an independent workplace investigation so the findings carry weight later.
-
Write down why you are not deciding yet. If business needs, a pending investigation or legal advice are the reasons for waiting, record that at the time. Littler's authors recommend that an employer who waits should be ready to show through contemporaneous evidence that it did not forgive or accept the conduct.
-
Avoid signals that the conduct was forgiven. Promotions, bonuses, new responsibilities or written praise during the delay period can all be read as acceptance. Tell the employee in writing that the matter is under review and that the employer reserves its right to respond.
-
Treat threats under your workplace violence program, not only as a discipline issue. Check whether the incident meets the OHSA definition, follow the investigation steps your program sets out, and take interim measures to protect the worker who was threatened. Our investigation readiness assessment is a quick way to test whether your process would hold up.
-
Get advice on the ESA question before you rely on it. Because the statutory wilful misconduct standard is higher than common law cause, have employment counsel review whether statutory termination pay is still owed before you withhold it.
The broader pattern in 2026 is consistent. Courts are looking closely at the quality and fairness of the process behind a dismissal, as Superior Court decisions earlier this year on bad faith investigations and just cause based on investigation findings also show. Warkentin adds a reminder that timing is part of that process.
Dealing with serious misconduct and not sure how fast to move? 1205 Consulting arranges and manages independent workplace investigations and helps HR teams build the record a dismissal decision depends on. Book a 30-minute consultation or contact us.
This article is general information, not legal advice.